Bonjour à tous,
I'd like to try a tcl object system, but I'm looking for a system that support a lite version in tcl only, so that I can keep an interpeted version of an application.
I know there is stooop which has the big advantage of beeing part of the tcllib. But I dont like C++ very much (:-), and I'm not sure there is a compiled version of stooop
There is itcl for which there is a tcl only lite version. The advantage of itcl is that it is very wide range ported, and it seems easier to install that xotcl. Also I is to be much like a standard tcl extension.
But I like the concept of xoctl, which seems more dynamic and powerfull than itcl, and keep the tcl phylosophy
So my question is : Does a tcl only version of xotcl exists (or about to exists) which would be a subset of xotcl.
The main fonctionnality I like is a simple inheritage feature and some introspection (which methods is supported by this class?, ...)
If such a xotcl-lite version could be put is the tcllib, then I think it would be the best mean to make xoctl widly use (and the the standard tcl object system)
Hi,
as far as I know, at the moment no such effort exists. In the very beginning of designing XOTcl, we had thought about it, but actually we came never back to this idea, though it is surely an interesting one. Our decision for the C-based solution was mainly based on efficiency considerations. However, now I'm pretty sure that a pure Tcl xotcl-lite would perform at a reasonable speed. Some things would be really tricky, but in a lite version most of them could be left out.
So the tcl only version idea is around for quite some while. If a few people would like to help building such a lite version I would definitely contribute, but at the moment, I fear, I don't have the time to start-off developing it on my own ... the problem is that starting off with something could be done relatively quick, but getting it to an industrial level so that its accepted in tcllib would be much, much more work ...
Uwe
On Saturday 06 July 2002 02:12 pm, Maurice Diamantini wrote:
Bonjour à tous,
I'd like to try a tcl object system, but I'm looking for a system that support a lite version in tcl only, so that I can keep an interpeted version of an application.
I know there is stooop which has the big advantage of beeing part of the tcllib. But I dont like C++ very much (:-), and I'm not sure there is a compiled version of stooop
There is itcl for which there is a tcl only lite version. The advantage of itcl is that it is very wide range ported, and it seems easier to install that xotcl. Also I is to be much like a standard tcl extension.
But I like the concept of xoctl, which seems more dynamic and powerfull than itcl, and keep the tcl phylosophy
So my question is : Does a tcl only version of xotcl exists (or about to exists) which would be a subset of xotcl.
The main fonctionnality I like is a simple inheritage feature and some introspection (which methods is supported by this class?, ...)
If such a xotcl-lite version could be put is the tcllib, then I think it would be the best mean to make xoctl widly use (and the the standard tcl object system)
Xotcl mailing list - Xotcl@alice.wu-wien.ac.at http://alice.wu-wien.ac.at/mailman/listinfo/xotcl
-
Maurice Diamantini -
Uwe Zdun